NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Monday witnessed a bizarre moment when the judges confused the lawyer, who appeared through a video conference, for an artificial intelligence .
As a lawyer appeared before the bench via video conferencing, justice BV Nagarathna asked, "Are you real?"
The advocate responded saying, "I can assure you Milord I am real", as quoted by Bar and Bench.
The exchange comes in the wake of reports from New York about an AI-generated entity making an appearance in court proceedings.
"There was a news today that a person made an AI person appear before the court and argue a case.. so are you the same?" justice SC Sharma said, citing the New York incident.
A 74-year-old man representing himself before a New York appellate court stunned judges by using an AI-generated avatar to deliver part of his argument. Jerome Dewald appeared before a panel of judges from the appellate division’s first judicial department seeking to overturn a lower court's ruling in a dispute with a former employer. Though not a licensed attorney, Dewald was allowed to present a prerecorded video in support of his argument.
The video, however, featured a much younger-looking man wearing a collared shirt and beige sweater, speaking against a blurred virtual background. The judges were quick to express confusion.
“That is not a real person,” Dewald replied, adding, “I generated that.”
The revelation drew an immediate rebuke from the judge, who said, “I don’t appreciate being misled.”
As a lawyer appeared before the bench via video conferencing, justice BV Nagarathna asked, "Are you real?"
The advocate responded saying, "I can assure you Milord I am real", as quoted by Bar and Bench.
The exchange comes in the wake of reports from New York about an AI-generated entity making an appearance in court proceedings.
"There was a news today that a person made an AI person appear before the court and argue a case.. so are you the same?" justice SC Sharma said, citing the New York incident.
A 74-year-old man representing himself before a New York appellate court stunned judges by using an AI-generated avatar to deliver part of his argument. Jerome Dewald appeared before a panel of judges from the appellate division’s first judicial department seeking to overturn a lower court's ruling in a dispute with a former employer. Though not a licensed attorney, Dewald was allowed to present a prerecorded video in support of his argument.
The video, however, featured a much younger-looking man wearing a collared shirt and beige sweater, speaking against a blurred virtual background. The judges were quick to express confusion.
“That is not a real person,” Dewald replied, adding, “I generated that.”
The revelation drew an immediate rebuke from the judge, who said, “I don’t appreciate being misled.”
You may also like
Several Harvard students lose visa, no reasons given; university refuses to share names
IPL 2025: Shahbaz Ahmed backs 'relaxed' Pant to fire as LSG brace for KKR challenge
Katherine Ryan slapped with £6000 bill for skin cancer diagnosis blood test
Egyptian, French Presidents voice rejection of displacement of Palestinians
Repo Rate: Good News! RBI May Cut Loan Rates Again, EMIs Could Get Cheaper
